|
Compact Coilgun
Theory
(If
you know how coilguns work, skip this paragraph)
The idea of a coilgun is that you make an
electromagnet by coiling wire
around a hollow tube, and then you get an iron
projectile and put it just outside the tube. To fire the gun,
you
send a large pulse of current through the electromagnet coil. It pulls
the iron projectile into it quickly. Then the pulse ends and
the
electromagnet turns off while the projectile is still moving, so it
continues moving and flies out the other side. Below is an animation
from the Wikipedia
coilgun page. It shows a coilgun version with three electromagnets in a
row.
For
the record, there is another type of coilgun which works
on a completely different principle. That type uses an aluminum or
copper (nonmagnetic) ring for the projectile. It is placed in front of
the coil. To fire, the coil is turned on quickly, which induces a
current in the ring, which makes the ring act like an electromagnet
pointed in the opposite direction. The two "North" poles repel, and the
ring is shot away from the coil. My coilgun doesn't work that way at
all, but I included the description here in case you've seen the ring
type and were confused. That effect is undesirable here because we're
trying to attract the iron into the coil, not repel it. That effect
does take a little bit of efficiency away from the iron-projectile
coilgun type.
My Circuit
The circuit that I use to produce the
current pulse is a Marx
Generator
modified to
use SCRs (explained below). The original Marx generator design uses
spark gaps and is
named for Erwin Marx, its inventor. His last name offends me though, so
I will call this modification the Adam Smith Generator, because it is
more practical to build and works efficiently.
(I'm sure this
modification
has been made by others too, but I haven't seen a catchy name
attached
to it. I'm also being a little facetious about the benefits of SCRs
over spark gaps. SCRs are better for my 300V design,
but spark gaps are better for
the very high voltages that the Marx Generator was designed
for.)
SCRs
The Adam Smith Generator uses Silicon-controlled
rectifiers (SCRs) to switch its current. SCRs are basically transistors that, once turned on, get stuck on until
the current
through
them stops, even if you remove the gate voltage. That is obviously
inconvenient, but their advantage is that they can handle larger
currents and voltages than regular transistors of the same size and
cost could. And they can handle even more current if it's a short
pulse.
So they're
a
very good switching device for coilguns, which need a short pulse of
high current. (The SCRs will
naturally turn off once the capacitor discharges and current stops.)
Design
The basic idea is that capacitors are charged in parallel but
discharged in series, so the voltage can be made higher than the
original voltage source. The Adam Smith Generator can be easily scaled
to supply current and voltage at any level. It charges its capacitors
with a 300V camera flash power supply from a disposable camera. The
capacitors are also from disposable cameras (more on that later, on the
Construction page.) The version of the circuit in my compact
coilgun gives the coil 600V when it fires. The circuit is below,
followed by an explanation of how it works.
Charging
In the Adam Smith
Generator, the SCRs are off
while the camera flash circuit charges the capacitors. So the
capacitors, connected by the charging resistors, charge in parallel
until each one has 300V. The equivalent circuit while charging is
below.
Firing
Then, to fire, the SCRs get turned on
(details of
that later). The resistance of the SCRs and of the coilgun's coil is
very low compared to the resistors, so very little current flows
through the resistors. (Also, the camera flash charging circuit turns
off
automatically after the capacitors have been charged, so it's out of
the picture too.) So basically the capacitors are connected in series,
so if two 300V capacitors are in series, the coil is getting
600V. The equivalent circuit while firing is below.
Triggering the SCRs
To
turn
on SCRs, you send a small current into their "gate" input.
Below
is the complete circuit, including the trigger part.
The
datasheet for my SCRs says you should send about 40mA into their gates
to turn them on. I tried to design the circuit to do roughly that. The
trigger circuit just takes the 300V from one of the capacitors and
sends it through a switch and some current-limiting resistors.
Other things to consider
SCR
peculiarities
I
worried a little about the fact that, once the SCRs turn on, their
voltages relative to the trigger circuit and each other change a lot.
However, my thinking is that, at the instant I push the switch, their
cathodes (the side where current comes out) will all be at about the
same voltage: the voltage of the
downstream side of the coil. That will only change when they start to
turn on. They should turn on at about the same speed, and once they're
on, they'll stay on, so I decided I didn't need to worry about it.
Another
feature of SCRs might come into play if the Adam Smith Generator were
expanded to a lot of capacitor stages: SCRs can also be turned on by a
sharp voltage rise across them, even if there's no input to the gate
(called a dV/dt turn on). Also, they turn on if the
voltage across them goes above their intended maximum operating
voltage. So for a Smith Generator of many stages, you would probably
only have to control the first few SCRs, and the later ones would be
turned on by one of those two effects. (I tried to test that by making
a
3-stage Smith Generator and only controlling the first two SCRs, but I
couldn't get the third to turn itself on. It might work with 4 stages
though; I haven't tried more than 3.)
Since
building this, I've discovered one problem in the circuit: if you
trigger the circuit, and then trigger it again when it's just starting
to recharge, the recharging current will go through the SCRs, keeping
them turned on, so the capacitors will never charge, and the charging
circuit will keep going until the battery runs out or you take it out.
This could be fixed in several ways, but I chose to just avoid doing
that.
Optimizing
and expanding the circuit
The Adam Smith Generator can be expanded to provide more voltage, a
longer current pulse, or both.
Voltage is increased by adding more capacitor
"stages," so more capacitors will be in series during discharge. A
higher voltage means a higher current, a stronger magnetic field from
the
coil, and more force on the projectile. It also means the capacitors
discharge sooner, so the current pulse will be shorter, which may or
may not be a good thing. Ideally, the current pulse should stop when
the projectile is in the center of the coil. If current is still
flowing after that point, it will be pulling the projectile backwards
and slowing it down. 900V gave me about 24 m/s, and 600V gave
me about 20 m/s. I
decided the extra 4 m/s wasn't worth the extra capacitor stage, so my
compact design uses 2 capacitors for 600V.
Besides
going to higher voltage, you can also increase the total energy by
putting two or more capacitors in parallel at each stage. Using two
parallel capacitors will double the capacitance (just like using a
capacitor that's twice as big) and double the length of the current
pulse, all else being equal. The circuit below is an example of an Adam
Smith
Generator with three stages (to make 900V) and two capacitors per
stage. Note that both adding stages and adding parallel capacitors will
increase the time needed to charge the circuit.
|